Understanding Greenhouse Covering Options
When it comes to selecting the right greenhouse covering, growers must balance insulation, cost, durability, and light diffusion to achieve optimal growing conditions. The four most common options are polycarbonate, polyethylene, SolaWrap, and glass, each with distinct advantages and drawbacks. This guide will help you compare these materials so you can make the best choice for your greenhouse.
Polycarbonate Greenhouse Covers
Overview: Polycarbonate is a rigid plastic material that provides excellent insulation and durability. It is available in single, double, and multi-wall sheets, with the multi-wall version offering the best thermal insulation.
Key Features:
-
Insulation: High thermal efficiency due to multi-wall construction.
-
Cost: More expensive than SolaWrap and polyethylene but cheaper than glass.
-
Durability: Shatter-resistant and long-lasting (10-15 years lifespan).
-
Light Diffusion: Blocks harmful UV rays and diffuses sunlight evenly.
-
Weight: Lighter than glass, making it easier to install.
-
Maintenance: Low-maintenance and resistant to yellowing over time.
Best For:
-
Growers in colder climates who need superior insulation.
-
Those looking for a long-term investment with minimal maintenance.
-
Greenhouses that require light diffusion to prevent plant scorching.
Polyethylene Greenhouse Covers
Overview: Polyethylene (PE) is a flexible, lightweight plastic sheeting commonly used in commercial and backyard greenhouses. It is an affordable and easy-to-install option but requires frequent replacement.
Key Features:
-
Insulation: Lower than polycarbonate but effective when double-layered.
-
Cost: The cheapest option.
-
Durability: Short lifespan (1-4 years), susceptible to tearing.
-
Light Diffusion: Available in clear and diffused options.
-
Weight: Extremely lightweight and requires secure fastening.
-
Maintenance: Needs frequent replacement, but repairs are easy.
Best For:
-
Budget-conscious growers.
-
Seasonal or temporary greenhouses.
-
High tunnel or hoop houses needing cost-effective coverage.
SolaWrap Greenhouse Covers
Overview: SolaWrap is an advanced polyethylene-based bubble film that provides long-lasting insulation and excellent light diffusion. Unlike standard polyethylene, it has a bubble structure that enhances durability and prevents plant scorching.
Key Features:
-
Insulation: Superior to standard polyethylene (R-Value 1.7-2.0).
-
Cost: Mid-range, more expensive than polyethylene but cheaper than glass.
-
Durability: Lasts 10+ years, resisting wind and hail.
-
Light Diffusion: Provides 83% diffused light, reducing hotspots.
-
Weight: Lightweight yet structurally strong.
-
Maintenance: Low-maintenance with high UV resistance.
Best For:
-
Growers looking for a long-lasting polyethylene alternative.
-
Greenhouses in harsh climates needing wind and hail resistance.
-
Those wanting cost-effective insulation without using polycarbonate.
Glass Greenhouse Covers
Overview: Glass is the traditional and most visually appealing greenhouse covering. It offers superior light transmission but is heavy, expensive, and prone to breakage.
Key Features:
-
Insulation: Good but not as efficient as polycarbonate.
-
Cost: The most expensive option.
-
Durability: Can last decades but is breakable.
-
Light Diffusion: Allows nearly 100% light transmission.
-
Weight: Heaviest option, requiring strong structural support.
-
Maintenance: Can accumulate dirt and algae, requiring regular cleaning.
Best For:
-
Permanent, high-end greenhouses.
-
Growers who prioritize maximum light transmission.
-
Those in mild climates where breakage from hail and storms is not a concern.
Comparative Analysis of Greenhouse Coverings
To help you visualize the differences, the following sections provide insight into insulation, cost, durability, and light diffusion.
1. Insulation (R-Value Comparison)
The R-value measures a material’s insulation ability; higher values mean better insulation.
| Greenhouse Covering | R-Value (Insulation Efficiency) |
|---|---|
| Polycarbonate | 1.5 |
| Polyethylene | 0.85 |
| SolaWrap | 1.8 |
| Glass | 1.0 |
2. Cost Analysis
The cost of greenhouse coverings varies based on material and lifespan.
| Greenhouse Covering | Cost per Square Foot (USD) |
| Polycarbonate | $3.50 |
| Polyethylene | $0.50 |
| SolaWrap | $2.50 |
| Glass | $6.00 |
3. Durability and Lifespan
The lifespan of each covering material significantly impacts long-term cost-effectiveness.
| Greenhouse Covering | Lifespan (Years) |
| Polycarbonate | 15 |
| Polyethylene | 3 |
| SolaWrap | 10-30 |
| Glass | 25 |
4. Light Diffusion & Transmission
Light diffusion affects how evenly plants receive sunlight.
| Material | Light Transmission (%) | Diffusion (%) |
| Polycarbonate | 80-90% | High |
| Polyethylene | 85% | Moderate |
| SolaWrap | 83% | High |
| Glass | 95-98% | Low |
Choosing the Right Greenhouse Covering for Your Needs
Key Takeaways:
-
For insulation: Choose polycarbonate or SolaWrap.
-
For affordability: Pick polyethylene.
-
For maximum light: Opt for glass.
-
For durability: Glass lasts the longest, but SolaWrap and polycarbonate resist impact.
-
For ease of installation: SolaWrap and polyethylene are easiest.
Final Recommendations:
-
Cold climates: Polycarbonate or SolaWrap.
-
Budget-conscious growers: Polyethylene.
-
Permanent, high-end greenhouses: Glass.
Conclusion
SolaWrap provides a high-tech alternative to polyethylene while offering insulation, longevity, and durability. Understanding these differences will help you make an informed decision that suits your greenhouse needs.
